A Fissure in the ‘Religious Right’, a victory in the culture war?

from the Washington Monthly: “In general, the most noticeable FISSURE among politically conservative evangelical Christians is generational. In this dynamic, OLDER evangelicals see themselves as an APPENDAGE of the Republican Party, and CONSIDER  abortion and gay rights as the only “moral” issues that matter. Younger evangelicals are LESS partisan, and CONSIDER poverty and global warming important, too.

But there’s ANOTHER fissure, which in the short term, may be even more consequential. It’s between leaders of the religious movement vs. those more inclined to take John 18:36 to heart (Jesus said, “My kingdom is not of this world”)….to the point that many “principled Christians” are now “FINISHED with politics.” Parker highlights a recent argument between Tom Minnery, head of the political arm of Focus on the Family, and Steve Deace of WHO Radio in Iowa.

Deace’s point was that established Christian activist groups too often SETTLE FOR LESSER EVILS IN EXCHANGE for electing Republicans…. Compromise may be the grease of politics, but it has no place in Christian orthodoxy, according to Deace.

Put another way, Christians may have NO place in the political fray of deal making. That doesn’t mean one disengages from political life, but it might mean that the church shouldn’t be a BRANCH of the Republican Party. It might mean trading fame and fortune (green rooms and fundraisers) for humility and charity…It’s hard to admit defeat, but this one was self-inflicted,” he( E. Ray Moore ) wrote in an e-mail. “Yes, Dr. Dobson and the pro-family or Christian right political movement is a FAILURE; it would have made me sad to say this in the past, but THEY have done it to themselves.”

For Christians such as Moore — and others better known, such as columnist Cal Thomas, a former vice president for the Moral Majority — the heart of Christianity is in the home, NOT the halls of Congress or even the courts. And the ROUTE to a more moral America is through good works — service, prayer and education — NOT political lobbying.

It’s worth noting that both sides of the fissure believe the CULTURE WAR HAS EFFECTIVELY BEEN LOST, but they differ wildly on the diagnosis. For religious right leaders, the culture war FLOPPED BECAUSE they faced too many enemies (popular culture, changing norms, progressive interest groups) with too few allies (no Republican follow-through). For those like Deace and Thomas, the war NEVER SHOULD HAVE BEEN FOUGHT in the first place, because it required principled Christians to effectively become political lobbyists.”

(EMPHASIS mine).  I might add, that as an advocate of the Establishment Clause, I have no problem with this turn.

see: http://www.washingtonmonthly.com/archives/individual/2009_04/017609.php

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.